/pone/ - World of Equestria

A board for discussing all things animated horse.

Posting mode: Reply

Check to confirm you're not a robot
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
Password
Drawing x size canvas
File(s)

Remember to follow the rules

Max file size: 350.00 MB

Max files: 5

Max message length: 4096

Manage Board | Moderate Thread

Return | Catalog | Bottom


CyTube Steam Catalog

Expand All Images


(1.96 MB 3001x1667 1689028.jpg)
Season 8 Thread Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:04:36 [Preview] No. 1060
It deserves a proper thread for the episodes that will come instead of using the main generals. Any discussion for the show especially season 8 and 9, is preferably posted in this thread.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:14:38 [Preview] No.1061 del
(87.81 KB 888x499 1689165.jpeg)
even though I have to watch the premiere again in order to judge it properly,I am mentioning one thing that caught me by surprise and made me emotional:

THE CASTLE OF THE TWO ROYAL SISTERS

HOLY shit, I think I may be the only one that loves that they have reused a place I wanted to see again and they left behind in season 4.
I love how it's easy to go there without caring but warning that Everfree Forest is still dangerous. That's a very little detail to point out but I cannot be happier that they have had that place in mind.

Also,I see that a certain character loves it more than me....so much that she cannot avoid her fetish for something as simple as....

Stairs.Eeeeyup,stairs.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:28:10 [Preview] No.1062 del
meanwhile I am leaving this for some room of discussion. I thought it was interesting to screencap the content the anon replied in the thread about the EEA doing nothing wrong.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:29:44 [Preview] No.1063 del
>>1062
also to clarify it,I posted ironically "fuck the EEA,we communism now" for making a bit the retard.
However,I didn't expect something of that value in that thread.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:47:28 [Preview] No.1064 del
(1.03 MB 1920x980 1521907765961.jpg)
>>1060

Nice to have a season discussion thread. Make things a little more organized

As for the Episode itself. I am right in between Meh, and Liking it. It wasn't horrible, there where somethings I was confused by, though it's hard to separate nitpics that shouldn't mater in a kids show with actual problems. Like the new characters way more then I thought I would. Will see if that stays throughout as they develop. Still won't be making any judgments on the school concept until I see more episodes and get a feel for the flow of things.

As for the reaction around the fandom, from what I've seen right now it's overall mixed positive. Will have yet to see if that will stay. /mlp/ was split. Some of course happy. Some hating SJW morals. Some thinking they were really subtle redpills, and some hating our Dolores. Though I did see a lot more mixed reactions rather then outright negative butthurt like I was expecting. I even saw an Ancap on /mlpol/ happy over it having what could be interpreted as an anti-government run education message. I personally think the new student characters helped it a good bit, because among even people who liked outside of chans I saw some butthurt/confusion on Chancellor Neighsay. Though were still a fair bit that liked him.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:50:05 [Preview] No.1065 del
>>1062
I honestly do think that is a message that can be taken away from that. It's not even the first time we've seen a message on "everybody learns differently" from MLP.


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 21:57:43 [Preview] No.1066 del
(1.04 MB 1226x1047 sheiskindofcute.png)
>1061
>HOLY shit, I think I may be the only one that loves that they have reused a place I wanted to see again and they left behind in season 4.

It was nice seeing it again. I will say that one of the criticisms I partly agree with is that the show has lost of it's more romantic and mysterious feel. Though agian I'm not in the hater camp, there was some implications and themes that were left behind a bit from the first 4 seasons. I'll post more about this and more detailed thoughts on the ep once I get my thought togather a bit better.

>Stairs.Eeeeyup,stairs.

A meme has been born!


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 22:01:52 [Preview] No.1067 del
(8.88 KB 345x103 TwilyIsANeocon.png)
For some reason this made me laugh quite a lot. I suppose you could losely fit that to the ep well, at least as a joke.

I may have to make something stupid related to this


Anon 03/24/2018 (Sat) 22:21:20 [Preview] No.1068 del
(996.99 KB 500x250 LeaveThemKidsAlone.gif)
>>1062
https://youtube.com/watch?v=YR5ApYxkU-U [Embed]


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 00:11:04 [Preview] No.1069 del
>>1064
>I am right in between Meh, and Liking it. It wasn't horrible, there where somethings I was confused by, though it's hard to separate nitpics that shouldn't mater in a kids show with actual problems.
It has much less plot holes that could bring a mess than The Crystal Empire or The Crystalling. You can try and check where the line is between your nitpicks and the problems you see though.

>Like the new characters way more then I thought I would. Will see if that stays throughout as they develop.
Surprisingly,they are pretty well defined for their debut,no way I would imagine I would enjoy their moment. so quickly like the Castle of the two sisters or the lake race between each other
.

>Still won't be making any judgments on the school concept until I see more episodes and get a feel for the flow of things.
The concept is under judgement,both inside the show and in the critic eye. It may not the be the most original setup but it's the most accesible one for reuniting all the species together.


>from what I've seen right now it's overall mixed positive. Will have yet to see if that will stay. /mlp/ was split. Some of course happy. Some hating SJW morals. Some thinking they were really subtle redpills, and some hating our Dolores.
Well, better than The Crystalling and around the same for Celestial Advice. Just as you would expect from them. I am chill about this,mostly because by the looks of the song of being together(in the preview),I thought this was about progressivism and stuff,but turns out it has ended pretty much in its own rule and context. Nor one side nor the other,just what they thought it was convenient or felt like doing it.
Dolores was again a sidekick for Twilight,just like Spike,she has served for some Twilight's reflections since her redemption. Even though I scream wow for the memes and laughs, she was an observer and just told her some advice.No deus ex machinas,mary sue nor she doesn't do anything wrong.She just gave her thoughts.

>Though I did see a lot more mixed reactions rather then outright negative butthurt like I was expecting. I even saw an Ancap on /mlpol/ happy over it having what could be interpreted as an anti-government run education message. I personally think the new student characters helped it a good bit, because among even people who liked outside of chans I saw some butthurt/confusion on Chancellor Neighsay. Though were still a fair bit that liked him.
Wow,an ancap having wet dreams,that's new. I mean,there are lots of interpretations about it but putting it as a form of rebel.... I am in for freedom of decisions but it's a must for everyone to keep the values and show what could be learnt from us.
The Chancellor did something of ambiguous. On one hand,he was right about having fears and paranoia of not following the patterns that have worked for a millenia. However,his values are pretty strict and while it may contain the best values out there,they are obnoxiously placed and forced because it has to be exactly that method.Also,he looked down at other species because his values don't serve for other species(and his morals or lessons could be universal,applying to everyone) but he excluded the "foreigners and almost created a world war because of that ego. That might explain why some find him confusing.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 00:24:14 [Preview] No.1070 del
(446.34 KB 1396x802 1689589.png)
>>1065
>It's not even the first time we've seen a message on "everybody learns differently" from MLP.
Eeyup,Testing Testing 1,2,3. Rainbow Dash learns by flying and not because of studying. I mean,learning from the books,while not the most inspiring method for nobody(appreciation grows over time,look at the 2nd song of this episode,they were interested),it's least bad method to learn it.
The problem comes when some are elitists about one way of learning or the other to the point where in real life,students with a career find themselves superior than others that haven't gone to university.

I remember someone saying that Asians hated that episode because they don't see it effective or they are obssesed to fill their minds with a book.
I mean,personally I think it's a great method but over time I think it serves for nothing if you cannot learn anything useful nor interesting from them that could be used for something. Learning is endless and infinite but when it's practical and experienced,the thing becomes much more accesible or affordable mentally,you see it clearer(Ocellus scene reading about the Castle of the Two Sisters and then Gallus said that school at least served for something).

So it actually serves I personally speak that while I have failed some technical subjects in my career, I have passed almost all the labs because I have experienced them and putting myself into the concept I am trying to learn.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 00:36:23 [Preview] No.1071 del
(295.67 KB 731x712 1689620.png)
>>1066
>It was nice seeing it again. I will say that one of the criticisms I partly agree with is that the show has lost of it's more romantic and mysterious feel.
It was lost since the Power Ponies episode happened. When you see the mane 6 going there so calmly alone,it means it's not all of that dangerous place but it's still surrounded by some passing menaces at times. It was pretty hostile in season 1 but it feels that the harmony effect has left a certain aura it. Not the safest place nor hostile.

>Though agian I'm not in the hater camp, there was some implications and themes that were left behind a bit from the first 4 seasons.
Babs Seed,Cadence's past, dragons and changelings were kind of left behind until season 6, so it was Iron Will and the cloning lake until season 7, Lightning Dust... there are things left and things that I would see them kind of pointless(Parasprites,Dragon Code...)
>A meme has been born!
And the next target for Rule 34. Expect some pictures that shows the stairway to heaven.

Her sudden transformation kind of caught me out of guard, I thought the seapony form was only applied when hippogriffs touched the water, not completely on earth. Novo transformed by splashing some water but this one had nothing of it. Still a quote and oh boi,the stairs....

Oh boi


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 00:51:52 [Preview] No.1072 del
>>1067
that's when you play with the metaphors hard. But it oddly fits so,someone could make a parody of this episode by applying that interpretation. Also,Twilight has had actual influence on US politics...phew
>>1068
Build the wall,Trump. We are another brick in the wall,kids learning like robots and the anarchist revolution happens because of constant pressure or order.
It seems like a joke but this actually fits for the episode,that happened after the first song when they were skipping class. It's like a lighter or kid friendly version of that rebel side.

What does our /end/ leader say about this? Do not burn the book,throw it to the water. The EEA is shit,go for what you know,not what they want you to know.

And that's how the school was born.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 01:48:10 [Preview] No.1073 del
(1.11 MB 1400x974 TwilyDoingItWrong.png)
>>1067
>mlpol doesn't love necontwily


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 02:35:39 [Preview] No.1074 del
(1.36 MB 1334x750 1521924081602.png)
>>1069
>It has much less plot holes that could bring a mess than The Crystal Empire or The Crystalling. You can try and check where the line is between your nitpicks and the problems you see though.
>Well, better than The Crystalling and around the same for Celestial Advice. Just as you would expect from them. I am chill about this,mostly because by the looks of the song of being together(in the preview),I thought this was about progressivism and stuff,but turns out it has ended pretty much in its own rule and context. Nor one side nor the other,just what they thought it was convenient or felt like doing it.

Yeah. Certainly wasn't the best. I can't say I hated it and it was slightly better then I expected it would be at some parts. It wasn't progressive shrilling, it was about tolerance + screw the rigid school system both as subtexts.

Okay, first I'm going to say what I liked. I liked the new characters (I mean, there is a possibility some of them could be annoying at times but I'm hopeful). Liked Dolores' moment with Twilight, she briefly popped in without feeling shoehorned in the plot and it actually was kind of sweet. Like many of the side moments, but I always like the tiny moments before stuff happens, so that's a given. I thought Twilight's character was handled okay, you could level some criticism at it, but it was stuff I would expect/could see their reasoning for. Natural evolution direction, it was actually interesting to see her use her authority as princess completely at her own at the end and her leaning to take charge a bit. though I suppose some would argue that she should already have some experience in that, I think her obsessiveness to follow the rules makes sense for how they handled it.


Now onto the otherstuff. This is probably going to be more of a ramble, but here it goes. EEA is... strange, not bad on paper, but it does feel a bit arbitrary. First off, Twilight Sparkle not knowing about the prime regulatory body for the Equestrian School system makes no sense to me, but I'm going to stop there. This point is a nitpick, because in the series she has had a few other moments like this. If you are going to give too much flank over that you have to remember her not knowing about stuff like the starswirl the bearded section in the canterlot library. Another thing odd about the EEA is how much power its implied to have. Now I really don't have a problem that there would be some bureaucracy that Celestia couldn't fix by degree on the get go well, they kinda implied that IDK , I mean with the hits even all the way back at the first gala that there was some royal duties that Celestia hated, but it sure seems strange how they conducted their power with a high level of impunity. He didn't even seem intimidated by the higher Princesses at all. Neighsay's attitude towards Twilight I actually think was a good writing choice. Though I think if this had been a few seasons back, Neighsay would've been paying faux politeness around the Princess and Twily would feel trapped in a different but similar way (Celestia, told me I need to get appoval from the EEA, but this guy's a total jerk, I don't know what to do! vs This guy is a total jerk who controls the EEA, I don't know what to do!). That actually could have made for an interesting dynamic in itself. TS feels that she hasn't to please him, then goes aganst him, and perhaps thinks she's going against Celestia too, Princess Celestia tells her that she has learned that a Princess had to take charge at times... bla bla bla.

I don't really as much about the bureaucracy as much as I felt they could have been more interesting with the dynamic here. At least another Twilight talking to Celestia at the end moment, celly saying I was pru=ound of you or something. Minus the Celestia and Twily not having a moment at the end, this isn't really much of a criticism as much is it me being confused by how all this works in their world.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 03:00:29 [Preview] No.1075 del
(105.14 KB 341x544 1521913834645.png)
>>1074
There only one true criticism I do have on that topic to Neighsay. At the very /end/ how he just attacked "everycreature" in front of Celestia. That... I just. He nearly started a major diplomatic incident and he wasn't fired for it. I mean you can say that he did back off. I just can't believe the impunity he showed at the end. Even if you could say he wasn't fired because many other ponies likely hold those views in authority, still the way he acted was beyond the bounds of the atmosphere of all that we have seen before with other government figures, who were all part of the "we secretly hate each other but we must act prim and propper" from everyone from Ms. Harshwhinny to the Canterlot elite and the few other higher up bureaucrats we've seen.

I won't have much a problem with him otherwise. I guess the thing was that they wanted to give him an aura of intimidation like a villain. I think they could've still had the same problem but it making slightly more sense, but Oh well, the only part I truly didn't like was how it was resolved.

Random other note: How was a pacing? The story for me actually flowed a little smoother then other times in mlp. Which surprised me because when I thought about it, did weeks or even months pass in setting up the school? What's that gonna do to the timeline? Ha ha!

>Her sudden transformation kind of caught me out of guard, I thought the seapony form was only applied when hippogriffs touched the water, not completely on earth. Novo transformed by splashing some water but this one had nothing of it.

Me too.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 03:09:26 [Preview] No.1076 del
>>1072
>that's when you play with the metaphors hard. But it oddly fits so,someone could make a parody of this episode by applying that interpretation. Also,Twilight has had actual influence on US politics...phew

Considering the fact that I was an someone who started to pay attention to politics around the early Obama years as a kid it almost brings back memories to me. Necon Twily is best almost meme.

>Build the wall,Trump. We are another brick in the wall,kids learning like robots and the anarchist revolution happens because of constant pressure or order.
It seems like a joke but this actually fits for the episode,that happened after the first song when they were skipping class. It's like a lighter or kid friendly version of that rebel side.

Kid friendly version of the rebel side is anoher import though lesser subtext of the ep methinks. Which could
probably be inferred in this order. Diversity > Screw Rigid School Bureaucracy > Kid friendly we need to buck the system.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 03:21:27 [Preview] No.1077 del
(34.14 KB 674x219 AncapsOnMLPOL.png)
(42.54 KB 1075x253 AncapsOnMLPOL2.png)
>>1069
>Wow,an ancap having wet dreams,that's new. I mean,there are lots of interpretations about it but putting it as a form of rebel.... I am in for freedom of decisions but it's a must for everyone to keep the values and show what could be learnt from us.

Freaky more then one on /mlpol/. Which is kind of funny. Though to be fair there is a lot of butthurt there anyways. Everywhere I've looked this time it's not as clear cut polarization that was season 6, though even in places that are accused of being hugboxs I've seen a bit more negativity then I'm used to. Time will tell.

I always try to look even in the most far off corners of the ponynet durring big events just to try gauge fan reaction


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 21:27:10 [Preview] No.1078 del
(280.09 KB 891x704 1204728.png)
>>1073
she cannot be Trump for them, you know but eh,it´s entertaining enough


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 21:39:22 [Preview] No.1079 del
(27.54 KB 605x301 1521991191265.png)
(53.01 KB 632x510 1521991309131.png)
>>1074
>it was about tolerance + screw the rigid school system both as subtexts.
basically, that stressful way of teaching the book line by line without any detour or a diffferent way to teach the same but with some clever differences, made the light rebellion

>it was actually interesting to see her use her authority as princess completely at her own at the end and her leaning to take charge a bit. though I suppose some would argue that she should already have some experience in that, I think her obsessiveness to follow the rules makes sense for how they handled it.
she treats the books as her religions and she has always been obsessive about certain things.Lesson Zero, What about Discord, the movie to put some examples proves that she cannot handle it as perfectly as she should but she has definitely gained some confidence over time.

>Twilight Sparkle not knowing about the prime regulatory body for the Equestrian School system makes no sense to me.
Consideering that she knows about how Equestria works, it´s really weird to see her surprised about that.

>this guy's a total jerk, I don't know what to do! vs This guy is a total jerk who controls the EEA, I don't know what to do!). That actually could have made for an interesting dynamic in itself.
Indeed,it could have lasted a few episodes for the build up and some duels between each other to see how deeply diferent views they have.

>this isn't really much of a criticism as much is it me being confused by how all this works in their world.
well, here there are the tweets from Jimmy. Basically all these stange things happened because of implementing the school alone. When you want to reach the eductaive all of a sudden (like the Cuite Map did with communism) then some context gets sacrificed in order to make some deep impact.

The 2nd tweet though....


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 21:58:09 [Preview] No.1080 del
(1.22 MB 1920x1080 1690120.png)
>>1075
>At the very /end/ how he just attacked "everycreature" in front of Celestia. That... I just. He nearly started a major diplomatic incident and he wasn't fired for it. I mean you can say that he did back off. I just can't believe the impunity he showed at the end. Even if you could say he wasn't fired because many other ponies likely hold those views in authority, still the way he acted was beyond the bounds of the atmosphere of all that we have seen before with other government figures, who were all part of the "we secretly hate each other but we must act prim and propper" from everyone from Ms. Harshwhinny to the Canterlot elite and the few other higher up bureaucrats we've seen.
That´s some kind of eerie and I hold the same views as yours. Even if he believed he was doing it for preventing future menaces for not educating properly; the egocentrism and superiority that annoyed the others (in front of a figure like Celestia nonetheless, wow) made his views fall apart. Like the paranoia took him beyond the consequences and remained untouched for saying that the 3 races of ponies are superior.

The diplmomatic views in the centre of Equestria seem elitism and that might explain view Celestia and Twilight are the friendly figures for external relationship, also explaining why ponies never went beyond the Everfree Forest nor had any interest to visit those far away places.
Ms Harshwhinny like you have said, showed that elitism and always looking down over the others until they change their minds. Not everything is so pinkish and colourful stuff in Equestria and that comes with a price of genuine racism.

>I guess the thing was that they wanted to give him an aura of intimidation like a villain.
or an antagonist. Some are making headcanons that he releases Tirek as revenge for the finale. I wouldn´t be surprised if that happened?

>How was a pacing? The story for me actually flowed a little smoother then other times in mlp.
Surprisingly well and not rushed at all for the resolution. The Crystalling had a lot of trouble with this, FiM, The Crystal Empire and The Cutie Map had certainly a rushed resolution. But this one flowed naturally and there were not only a clear moral but some interesting essages throughout the episode. That shows the different levels we have reached in this ride. From simple letters to actual problems that irl we discuss and have trouble facing certain things currently.

>did weeks or even months pass in setting up the school? What's that gonna do to the timeline? Ha ha!
Magic happened. Surely the creators can answer this...>>1079


well,maybe not


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 22:10:54 [Preview] No.1081 del
>>1076
>Necon Twily is best almost meme.
BREAKING NEWS on the CNN!
Twilight has broken the rules of the EEA!
Neighsay confirmed for hate speech in front of Celestia!
Changeling almost deported for being homo weirdos!
World War almost happening!Blame that neocon alicorn for ruining the fun!
Celestia confirmed as a less authoritarian figure than the EEA and she in theory, rules Equestria!
Chancellor Neighsay secret plans revealed. Building a wall from the Everfree Forest to the Crystal Empire confirmed. "Those species are inferior" as posted in his latest Ponitter.

So many clickbait headlines could be made from this.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 22:20:10 [Preview] No.1082 del
>>1076
>Kid friendly version of the rebel side is anoher import though lesser subtext of the ep methinks. Which could
probably be inferred in this order. Diversity > Screw Rigid School Bureaucracy > Kid friendly we need to buck the system.
All this stuff complaining about the race and superficial yet tiring topic as that one when you get the message of kids getting fed up of the bureaucracy. Only to serve the EEA purposes, ponies built and educated to do the usual things andf not getting out of the path.
Making them as future mindless bricks in the wall.... and skipping classes skipping happens.Bam, part 1 of the opener.


Anon 03/25/2018 (Sun) 22:34:40 [Preview] No.1083 del
>>1077
>that are accused of being hugboxs I've seen a bit more negativity then I'm used to. Time will tell.
they are used to hearing their own eccochambers, which funnily enough we do. Anyway those reactions are worth to see and point out sometimes. Sometimes the reflections about how a desirable society for an individual should work comes into this innocent things.
The episode actually went with some rebel spirit and putting some competiotion on education between Twilight and the EEA. As the Chancellor said, let´s see how it works but I think Twilight has got morals and values that the EEA didn´t have.
And that could lead to some really divergent views on seeing how a society should work. Twilight acknowledges how a school should work and see that there has to be some principles but not as far as the EEA had gone with it.
Dolores was right. Twilight HAS DIPLOMATIC values and morals while the EEA didn´t bother on advancing in that point. This means that the view from the EEA won´t be the dominant view anymore and that Twilight holds a much external and universal view on how to give values from her experiences.

It´s ancap but it also comes from systematic criticism. Breaking the rules for what was done in the past means a new system and maybe, the new mainstream of how things should work. That has happened with art,music and lots of things, rebuilding the idea from nothing and give a future guide for a new generation.

I have to mention that discussing about this episode is deeper than expected and damn, I usually forget that we are discussing about a thing like MLP. That has escalated quickly again in 2018.


Anon 03/27/2018 (Tue) 03:27:46 [Preview] No.1086 del
(2.53 MB 1920x1080 1522108527972.png)
>>1079
>she treats the books as her religions and she has always been obsessive about certain things.Lesson Zero, What about Discord, the movie to put some examples proves that she cannot handle it as perfectly as she should but she has definitely gained some confidence over time.

Exactly.

>Consideering that she knows about how Equestria works, it´s really weird to see her surprised about that.

Again, the show has done this before, so I'm not going to hold it aginst them too strongly, but she has displayed a familiarity with Government before and was the type of pony who seeked out knowledge on the most mundane to advanced things on a subject. You'd think she'd know about them, at least there existence. She went to the School for gifted unicorns, if they are such a regulatory body you'd think there would be "time for the EEA inspection" EEA approved stamps or something of the short she had to have seen. Not to mention asking Celestia about all forms all the various operations of Government.

>Indeed,it could have lasted a few episodes for the build up and some duels between each other to see how deeply diferent views they have.

It would have been interesting if his xenophobia was more subtle, and put more emphasis to him seeing Twilight as somepony who was too young and reckless and needed to be reigned in/managed. Agreed, he could have been cooler as a consistent political enemy.

>The diplmomatic views in the centre of Equestria seem elitism and that might explain view Celestia and Twilight are the friendly figures for external relationship, also explaining why ponies never went beyond the Everfree Forest nor had any interest to visit those far away places.

Elitism of the top, plus fear considering some of the threats we've seen. Equestria itself is not fully untamed either at least it used to be Monsters in the everfree. And hostile actors acting within walking distance to Ponyville such as the Diamound Dogs, along with not the best relations with some of their neighbors until recently in the form of the buffalo. A head cannon I used to have too was that long range transport wasn't that well developed do to us use to seeig them only walking on hoof or on train for at least a day and night, but with all the outings recently to other counires and far off lands in a single ep, I'm not sure how well that holds up. Though I suppose we do have the answer Cartoon Logic


Anon 03/27/2018 (Tue) 03:39:42 [Preview] No.1087 del
>>1080
>That´s some kind of eerie and I hold the same views as yours.
>Like the paranoia took him beyond the consequences and remained untouched for saying that the 3 races of ponies are superior.

Again, I could picture a bureaucrat who can't be removed at the flick of a pen, or I guess in this case a quill. I'm still trying to wrap my head at where this leaves things in terms of Equestria's government structure. Though not the most detailed thing that has everything spelled out for us, the EEA seems to conflict a pretty good deal with what we've seen before.I'm not even just talking about in terms of the political powers of the Princesses either. I will detail my thoughts once I check through the cannon to show ya what I mean.

>or an antagonist. Some are making headcanons that he releases Tirek as revenge for the finale. I wouldn´t be surprised if that happened?

That could be interesting.


Anon 03/27/2018 (Tue) 04:07:01 [Preview] No.1088 del
(185.16 KB 823x1000 973002.jpg)
>>1083
>It´s ancap but it also comes from systematic criticism. Breaking the rules for what was done in the past means a new system and maybe, the new mainstream of how things should work. That has happened with art,music and lots of things, rebuilding the idea from nothing and give a future guide for a new generation.

Sometimes in ways not even the original revolutionaries envisioned. It could also lead to the acceptance of this form along with the old still existing, but not absolute any more.

>I have to mention that discussing about this episode is deeper than expected and damn, I usually forget that we are discussing about a thing like MLP. That has escalated quickly again in 2018.

I know the fandom runs with things, but man there is a lot more deeper implications and meanings then one would expect for a show of this caliber. I mean I never thought I'd watch a show about ponies teaching about friendship, and then I never thought I'd speculate how there government and society function, not to mention actually having some stuff to actually make a fair guess on a few things.

>>1081

Will Princess Twilight Finally tackle education reform?
Local School Boards criticize handling of Friendship School controversy
Fancy Pants long a champion of education reform and school choice, applauses Friendship School in opt-ed to the Equestria Daily
Survey, over 80 % of Equestrian Educators have never heard of the EEA. EEA spokespony blames lack of resources for enforcement of rural schools.


Anon 03/27/2018 (Tue) 21:35:23 [Preview] No.1089 del
>>1087
>I will detail my thoughts once I check through the cannon to show ya what I mean.

Equestria's Government never was really the most defined thing in the world, but the assumption that most of the fandom held was that it was an absolute monarchy of some sort. We've seen that the Princes granted land to form ponyville to the Apple family.We have seen Equestria apparently having no leadership and the guards freakout without the presence of Princess in Princess Twilight Sparkle. We've also seen the Princess serve roles of both minor and significant arbitration over ponies Trade Ya! and more importantly in A Royal Problem with the dispute Fillydelphia and Baltimare as if they would be the final authority on such matters. Though I actually can buy ponies that Celestia can't remove easily, I would think his conduct way more then justified it, so it does make me question how much hard power the Princesses do hold.

Now I've heard of examples being mentioned in the past in reguards to the comics having a few things that suggest more checks and balances, but I wasn't able to find anything in my search at the moment though I hadn't followed the comics the best. I can't recall anything off the top of my head other then the good, the bad and the ponies arch where Twilight said that she couldn't use her magic against citizens of equestria. Which was done in a very arbitrary and weird way for the sake of the plot to last longer, and maybe contradicted by her use of magic in The Hooffields and McColts. The comics are secondary canon that are oftentimes ignored and sometimes directly contraindicated in the show, but I won't fully discount them.

Though honestly what I find more strange is how centralized the EEA seemed. Again, not completely impossible to exist, sense this show obviously wasn't going to spell out things for us . But most other high level bureaucratic functions have been implied to be divided on both between both what race you were and also regionally. The Clouddale authorities controlled the weather, yet with things such as Spike saying in winter wrap up that the unicorns use magic to clear the weather and implications that various towns have their own traditions at least between the pony races . Plus the fact that Ponyvile itself seeming to have some authority on how the weather schedules is handled suggested some anatomy here as well. Usually the highest bureaucratic reperitives outside of the Princesses were either some authorities for race specific things or just on a city level. My theory on Equestria's government before this was that it was some kind of very flat pyramid structure, with not much in between the Princesses and the various towns and cities that existed. The Princess had a bunch of individual obligations to various towns both small and large that seemed to reinforce this notion. The aftermentioned dispute in A royal problem is what really finalized it for me, though my thoughts had drifted in that direction all the way back in It's About Time, where Twilight Sparkle sent the Ponyville Pegasi to warn the cities on a individual basis. The EEA seems to conflict with both those ideas, seemly authority that is both rigid and extremely centralized, rather then Pegasi being the ones in charge of flight certifications and weather and Unicorns being the ones in charge of magic, and earth ponies either being on a town by town basis or having some sort of bureaucracy that is in charge of there schools.

Welp, I felt like I was a bit rambly, but I think you get my point. Though I suppose there is something somehwere that could perhaps conflict with everything I said, but that's what you get for over analyzing a little girls show.


Anon 03/27/2018 (Tue) 22:40:26 [Preview] No.1090 del
(777.99 KB 1280x929 the student six.png)
>>1089
>Welp, I felt like I was a bit rambly, but I think you get my point. Though I suppose there is something somehwere that could perhaps conflict with everything I said, but that's what you get for over analyzing a little girls show. I think I see where you are going into with your interpretation but
this will take a while to reply properly.But yeah, we are going to levels that even DBZ would like to have this level of depth.
And funnily enough, that anime also involves friendship in Super.

Anyway,I am replying now just to give a sign of having read your posts but it will take a me a bit for making non shitposting replies.
I am leaving these six newcomers over here


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 04:10:50 [Preview] No.1092 del
(164.89 KB 522x531 DaPrincesRememberBRO.png)
>>1090
>Anyway,I am replying now just to give a sign of having read your posts but it will take a me a bit for making non shitposting replies.

No rush, not like I'm been 100% in replying to everything you post in a timely manner.

>I think I see where you are going into with your interpretation

This btw, isn't a headcanon that I held near and dear to my heart, just kinda the way I imagined it based on what I saw on the show.

>we are going to levels that even DBZ would like to have this level of depth.
And funnily enough, that anime also involves friendship in Super.

Never saw much of DBZ, but knowing that style of logic, things happen because reasons, I'd almost be willing to wager that while not being as interconnected from episode to episode, MLP has a harder continuity in some ways. Also, though I know friendship is a trope MLP did't invent, it's still hilarious when I hear of the concept being used someplaces else to me.





>>1089
> We've seen that the Princes granted land to form ponyville to the Apple family.

Yeah, ya know the Princes? Blueblood and maybe Fancy Pants, totally not a mistake made I my part. Most fans just remember the ep wrong. {/sarcasm}


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 22:02:04 [Preview] No.1095 del
>>1086
>she has displayed a familiarity with Government before and was the type of pony who seeked out knowledge on the most mundane to advanced things on a subject
she would have probably heard about something during the periods as a princess in Canterlot. She studies everything before doing anything. Twilight doesn´t know how to improvise orat least, not her strongest aspect for such confidence in their regulations.

>you'd think there would be "time for the EEA inspection" EEA approved stamps or something of the short she had to have seen.
Or probably like I heard somewhere in /mlp/, maybe it´s recommended to get the approval in order to have recognition and official image, as a certificate to porve that it´s approved by their standards.
When you want to have a laboratory or industry, you can have it. However, you have to pass some tests during certain periods of time in order to check the quality of your products. It´s NOT mandatory but it´s absolutely recommended and highly encouraged just for receiving good publicity, an image of guaranteed quality and some external help for contributing and making an effort for keeping your products safe by health measures. If you don´t have it, your lab/industry can exist but your image and security standards wouldn´t gain the trust of many potential customers because they want the products already tested and approved before consuming them.
This is what more or less,applying this analogy to the EEA what I can get from it.

>he could have been cooler as a consistent political enemy.
we have yet to see his background context or motifs. We only know that he almost fucked it up.

>Equestria itself is not fully untamed either at least it used to be Monsters in the everfree.
Everfree has ended up as big forest.Maybe the highly menacing image from it was because ponies hadn´t had the courage to visit it a lot of times like the mane 6 and exxagerated its a image by a mile.
Again, going to the Castle of the Two Sisters alone or to Zecora house without blinking is basically pissingly easy. Instead of being friendly, it´s just a wild place that has genuinely dark places but those aren´t so random as they have feared(the swamp fever lake, the dragon hidden in a cavein season 1, the Diamond dogs or the furby creatures. They are kind of predictable and located, but when you have visited it so many times, you stop caring.

>that long range transport wasn't that well developed do to us use to seeig them only walking on hoof or on train for at least a day and night, but with all the outings recently to other counires and far off lands in a single ep
Train transport is the shit in Equestria and t´it´s a shame that they had to do like Majora´s Mask with the owls,until you don´t active them, no teleport. Here it´s the same, once you visit a new area,bam train station for whenever you want to use it. New place, new accesible route for all the family. Not sure if they have established one with Griffonstone, the Changeling hive or the Badlands but I will tell you(very light spoilers)that they visit Mount Aris with a train. It seems pretty far from Ponyville but they visit it like nothing in comparison to the movie.
>Cartoon Logic
Of course darling.


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 22:13:28 [Preview] No.1096 del
>>1087
>I'm still trying to wrap my head at where this leaves things in terms of Equestria's government structure.
We all do,we have speculated about Celestia for years and this comes late in the show to reveal that what something implied worked turns out it isn´t what it seems.


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 22:36:22 [Preview] No.1097 del
>>1088
>It could also lead to the acceptance of this form along with the old still existing, but not absolute any more.
Agreed
>there is a lot more deeper implications and meanings then one would expect for a show of this caliber.
Not even Faust would have thought about this back in 2010. Literally nobody, neither you and me nor all the pony boards could have expected this potential from a laughable franchise.

>I never thought I'd watch a show about ponies teaching about friendship, and then I never thought I'd speculate how there government and society function, not to mention actually having some stuff to actually make a fair guess on a few things.
That´s what most plebs and people in general tend to believe at first, but instead of being an innocent show,it´s us who are the innocents about looking down on it before. Sure it´s not Game of Thrones, but damn specualting about the lore and how the system works has made us talk a lot more than expected. This episode receives a high rating from me in terms of creating discussion and finding a critique about the education system. All of this with the typical students who are just getting to know each other and simply like to have fun. Amazing that the show is able to be simple yet, clever on certain details.

>Survey, over 80 % of Equestrian Educators have never heard of the EEA. EEA spokespony blames lack of resources for enforcement of rural schools.
That´s a good one. Those who critisize are like music critics to albums, they are failed musicians that got into critics. More of the same,those are failed teachers.

>Fancy Pants long a champion of education reform and school choice, applauses Friendship School in opt-ed to the Equestria Daily
We have some polarizing opinions here. Damn, this seems like the Last Jedi reviews.
>Will Princess Twilight Finally tackle education reform?
We will see in the next episode of Dragon Ball Super.


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 23:01:11 [Preview] No.1098 del
>>1089
>but the assumption that most of the fandom held was that it was an absolute monarchy of some sort.
Everything is made of implication,what could we expect from an implying site?

>so it does make me question how much hard power the Princesses do hold.
Maye she is like a figure but she cannot hold too much in order to not have rebels or seem authoritarian.

>Maybe contradicted by her use of magic in The Hooffields and McColts. The comics are secondary canon that are oftentimes ignored and sometimes directly contraindicated in the show.
She used magic on them but it was a move to make them stop, not use it as a weapon. She has used it with the mane 6 before. Again, there is not a holy bible nor solid principles to clarify what should be done or not. Using the comics is certainly not the most indicated way to inform, just treating them as some bonus or optional addition to some random things.

>Though honestly what I find more strange is how centralized the EEA seemed.
>unicorns use magic to clear the weather and implications that various towns have their own traditions at least between the pony races . Plus the fact that Ponyvile itself seeming to have some authority on how the weather schedules is handled suggested some anatomy here as well.
>The EEA seems to conflict with both those ideas, seemly authority that is both rigid and extremely centralized, rather then Pegasi being the ones in charge of flight certifications and weather and Unicorns being the ones in charge of magic, and earth ponies either being on a town by town
There is certainly some conflict to their purpose. Not going to say that it´s flawed but this seems that while the EEA checks the standards of education for the three races, it has more power than the princesses when it comes to this.
I would focus more that the EEA had mixed and treated Ponyville as the place of harmony between the three races just to remember that Ponyville was the place they got together. Meanwhile,Canterlot, Appleloosa and Cloudsdale seem to be clearly separated between them.
I swear that maybe ponies were complete elitists and that many of them cannot hold the mixture between them that well as if it was implied. Maybe the pink paradise was the result of giving themselves a chance first and more of an established harmony as seasons have come by.They know each other an can treat themselves fine but those separate locations and the first visits to their places save certain events could actually mean that they have hold some elitism until they have seen menaces like the Changelings or Tirek. When those disgraces and hard moments happen, they get more empathy and their little (but potentially used as an elitist weapon) are left behind and mean nothing to their friendships.

Phew lad.
>there is something somehwere that could perhaps conflict with everything I said, but that's what you get for over analyzing a little girls show
everything is somewhat convenient for the plot but what show doesn´t have those conflics(in a show about conflicts and morals nonetheless). Overanalyzing it and taking it too seriously have driven us to this point. Maybe it´s not a healthy practice but let´s keep going to see what happens. Maybe WoW or Tolkien could fear and envy about the pony lore at some point(oh boy, I hope I get to be alive if that happens)


Anon 03/28/2018 (Wed) 23:17:58 [Preview] No.1099 del
(1.84 MB 5067x4245 1690888.png)
>>1092
>I'm been 100% in replying to everything you post in a timely manner.
well, for >>1089 you have postponed the headcannons for the next day. Not going to say that mines are rushed, but sure I have to be focused on what I am saying. It´s going naturally these days, but writing properly a foreign language that you barely talk in real life, makes someone to put a bit more of attention on it.

>I'd almost be willing to wager that while not being as interconnected from episode to episode, MLP has a harder continuity in some ways. Also, though I know friendship is a trope MLP did't invent, it's still hilarious when I hear of the concept being used someplaces else to me.
MLP has received a boost on continuity since A Canterlot Wedding. I consider from season 3 onwards involving some continuity and this reaches its peak with season 4 premiere and finale. Once in that point, everyhting involves some context(not a complex one though).
In DBZ, you can enjoy an episode of two having a battle most of the time, just like a normal episode with a slice of Life lesson. For example, despite being so advanced in the show, you can enjoy Secrets and Pies,Discordant Harmony or The Saddle Row Review with hardly or no context at all. However, some eps like To Change A Changeling or Shadow Play are developed after certain events.
I however, see that MLP and DBZ are much close than one could think. DBZ seems like a serious show on sight for everyone but has a sense of comedy or chill moments between the serious battles. MLP is in reverse, a childish setting with the most girly species considered in the industry with over the seasons, dark stuff implied between its "childish" soul. A Health of Information is dark as hell(no seriously, it gave me genuine fears after thinking about it,it´s surprisingly much darker than what it´s shown), School Daze has proved to stand as a genuine critique to the education system, the Cutie map, Flight to the Finish......for the kids, in theory.

I let the digits post to you.


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 02:01:27 [Preview] No.1100 del
>>1095
>she would have probably heard about something during the periods as a princess in Canterlot. She studies everything before doing anything.

That as well. If she hadn't have heard of it before you'd think that, considering how obsessively she studies, she would have then at least.

>Or probably like I heard somewhere in /mlp/, maybe it´s recommended to get the approval in order to have recognition and official image, as a certificate to porve that it´s approved by their standards.

I heard that as well, but it just seemed that they were a bit more than that by how they shut the school down.

>Maye she is like a figure but she cannot hold too much in order to not have rebels or seem authoritarian.

I honestly could buy that. Perhaps more of commander in chief and the highest arbitrator but has relatively little non ceremonial power besides that.

>1098
>There is certainly some conflict to their purpose. Not going to say that it´s flawed but this seems that while the EEA checks the standards of education for the three races, it has more power than the princesses when it comes to this.

I won't call t flawed either, just a quite different then what was implied/assumed before. It doesn't really bug me that much. In some ways a joint authority would make a lot of since from a unity of the races perspective. The show before just showed only authorities such as the flight school and magic school being between the races. With stuff like the Grand Equestria Summit, Equestria Games, and the dispute between mayors in A Royal Problem leading to such a feel of a decentralized system. Not to mention the little conflicts we saw on Equestria's frontiers. But hey, it's a kids show. so it has to be simple in its presentation (though that logical thread is what lead me to that conclusion in the first place, figuring that would probably the only way I'd see it on screen). We weren't ever intended to see much of the internal politics and things would be broken down into simpler concepts. The EEA was designed to teach a lesson and service an episode rather then lore.

>we have yet to see his background context or motifs. We only know that he almost fucked it up.

True. He is supposed to appear again I hear. Wonder if will get more background that may help explain things?

>I let the digits post to you.

Thanks, though ya take the next one, Okay? I think this is the 3rd time in a row ya given them to me. You deserve them too. Yay for digits!


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 02:32:54 [Preview] No.1101 del
>>1097
>That´s what most plebs and people in general tend to believe at first, but instead of being an innocent show,it´s us who are the innocents about looking down on it before. Sure it´s not Game of Thrones, but damn specualting about the lore and how the system works has made us talk a lot more than expected.

There was just enough thought put into it to give us tidbits to speculate on. Faust wasn't trying to create a deep lore, but she did have set rules on how the world worked and some possible secrets which she never thought would get any attention . Just enough to start to theorize and connect dots early on. Then post Faust they started to leave fan service, then later on full on lore.

>>1099
>MLP has received a boost on continuity since A Canterlot Wedding. I consider from season 3 onwards involving some continuity and this reaches its peak with season 4 premiere and finale. Once in that point, everyhting involves some context(not a complex one though).

Season 1 had a few rules and subtexts that Faust put in a background ambiance.
Season 2 had fan service.
Season 3 started to give us breadcrumbs of lore
Season 4 was the fulfillment of this linear path. With anything past more at the whims of the who was writing in service of what. Either lore, fan service or something that they'd think would be a good lesson and sometimes all the above

>>1098
>She used magic on them but it was a move to make them stop, not use it as a weapon. She has used it with the mane 6 before. Again, there is not a holy bible nor solid principles to clarify what should be done or not.

The problem was she wouldn't do any force whatsoever. Not even magical diplays or threats despite the fact that the gang was attacking them. It was just an stupid thing to keep the plot going.

>Using the comics is certainly not the most indicated way to inform, just treating them as some bonus or optional addition to some random things.

That's the best way to treat them for sure. Especially ones with stuff like Nightmare Rarity.


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 03:32:15 [Preview] No.1102 del
>>1099
>Not going to say that mines are rushed, but sure I have to be focused on what I am saying. It´s going naturally these days, but writing properly a foreign language that you barely talk in real life, makes someone to put a bit more of attention on it.

You're doing a better job then me. I often am rushing myself because of the possibility of interruptions and catch the errors later!

>MLP is in reverse, a childish setting with the most girly species considered in the industry with over the seasons, dark stuff implied between its "childish" soul. A Health of Information is dark as hell(no seriously, it gave me genuine fears after thinking about it,it´s surprisingly much darker than what it´s shown), School Daze has proved to stand as a genuine critique to the education system, the Cutie map, Flight to the Finish......for the kids, in theory.

For me its always darker when something is in the background or a subtext when you think of it long enough you go "Oh, well now my I will proceed to have nightmares" A Health Of Information creeped me out more because of how subtly integrated and well it worked in that world. I agree 220%.


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 03:36:44 [Preview] No.1103 del
(418.41 KB 840x1050 1596105.jpeg)
>We all do,we have speculated about Celestia for years and this comes late in the show to reveal that what something implied worked turns out it isn´t what it seems.

I wonder if this will have any ramifications on how they portray things or will it just be an arbitrary force confined to a couple of eps. Guess will just have to wait and see!


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 22:57:03 [Preview] No.1106 del
(177.65 KB 760x689 1694027.png)
>>1100
>it just seemed that they were a bit more than that by how they shut the school down.
well, that ruins my headcanon of being optional.
>Perhaps more of commander in chief and the highest arbitrator but has relatively little non ceremonial power besides that.
A figure more than anything. It happens with the contemporary monarchies. They are the first subject for the land but also, the one that has to represent and give example to others. No wonder Celestia happens to teach and give good values to new generations.

>The EEA was designed to teach a lesson and service an episode rather then lore.
A simple plot device... most likely yes. It´s up to future episodes featuring the Chancellor and his motifs. Maybe he could have cheated on Celestia before in order to get that position. MLP introduces a lot of short term plot devices that after some time, get expanded or more relevant the less you expect it. The EEA explanation is up to his next roles in season 8.
>Wonder if will get more background that may help explain things?
Before I have managed to reply this, I have thought the same.

>I think this is the 3rd time in a row ya given them to me. You deserve them too
inb4 a random poster takes them while I am making a detailed reply.
Also checked


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 23:16:43 [Preview] No.1107 del
(435.89 KB 1600x1600 1690066.png)
>>1101
>Just enough to start to theorize and connect dots early on. Then post Faust they started to leave fan service, then later on full on lore.
Money comes into the party and that progression comes slowly by the time you realize the audience interested on the show. you see that season1 had random things that were never intended to explained but those little random things got more advanced and even essential to upper the quality and give some flow to the show. Gilda was a random friend, Trixie was just a random pony to test Twilight on magic tricks, Snails was a complete idiot because idiots have to exist in every show,the Pie family was just a simple family and Maud wasn´t not even there in Cuite Mark Chronicles...

>With anything past more at the whims of the who was writing in service of what. Either lore, fan service or something that they'd think would be a good lesson and sometimes all the above
Well, everything seems to be connected these days. Now, nothing is as random as before and if it seems so, most of the times has a certain background applied into it that reinforces the simple idea. Season 7 for example, Campfire Tales is just an episode about old fairy tales and legendary stories of very old figures, far away from the dynamic of the curerent situation, just to teach morals to the kids...and then, bam they were real and they come back to life in the current timeline and that implies the so awaited Starswirl.
Just old campfire stories right?

>It was just an stupid thing to keep the plot going.
The best thing to come out from Hoffields and Mccolts was Fluttershy,a reference like the Troyan horse tactic and serve for the episode of Flutershy Leans In. The rest was nothing special.

>Especially ones with stuff like Nightmare Rarity.
I wonder how much effect the comic characters have by introducing them into the gameloft pay to consume game. Nightmare Rarity would have been a good arc. A Royal Problem was based exactly on the plot from a comic, just that instead of featuring the princesses only, Dolores goes there with the map plot device


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 23:36:13 [Preview] No.1108 del
(1.44 MB 1959x1079 1540249.png)
>>1102
>I often am rushing myself because of the possibility of interruptions and catch the errors later
the posts don´t give the rushed vibes to me. Or at least, I cannot get what it´s rushed or not so easily. I however, notice when a post is cheap. Explaining something with more details can be solved easily with another post.

>A Health Of Information creeped me out more because of how subtly integrated and well it worked in that world.
I am always mentioning that episode a lot because it seems like filler that who would the hell would care. But when you let it enter into your mind genuinely, the experience doesn´t end when you have finished the episode.

>when you think of it long enough you go "Oh, well now my I will proceed to have nightmares"
Eeyup, basically this. It puts a lot of plot devices into a 22 one. Introducing Meadowbrook(lore), the swamp fever lake, the menacing part which is nobody but nature being a bitch to everyone(nobody to blame), Fluttershy going beyond her fears and efforts in her last steps, both Zecora and FS under the worse than death consequences and the moral of taking care of yourself (a very realistic and simple one).
Add to it that humans can absolutely relate to this and that a virus or epidemic illness could remove all of us without seeing nor capable to kill the source of it. MLP being an 80s show.


Anon 03/29/2018 (Thu) 23:41:28 [Preview] No.1109 del
(1.04 MB 1000x1400 1686866.png)
>>1103
>I wonder if this will have any ramifications on how they portray things or will it just be an arbitrary force confined to a couple of eps.
We may never know but seeing Celestia for bigger roles in the next episodes is always welcome.


Anon 03/31/2018 (Sat) 19:35:44 [Preview] No.1111 del
WE ARE NUMBER ONE ONE ONE ONE

technically


Anon 04/01/2018 (Sun) 05:10:40 [Preview] No.1116 del
>>1111
We reached one one one one! A proud achievement indeed.

I have a lot of stuff to reply to, plus looking up the new episode. Sorry I didn't reply to your stuff yesterday, I wanted you to get the trips.

Things have been a tiny bit hectic but Tommorow or the next hopefully I'll have cached the newest episode and I'll put down my thoughts on it. Along with the aforementioned stuff I need to reply too.


= 04/02/2018 (Mon) 00:39:00 [Preview] No.1132 del
>>1116
>Sorry I didn't reply to your stuff yesterday, I wanted you to get the trips.
No problem. I had perfectly noticed that you wanted to let me some digits but not these ones so soon. So I put a very seemingly random image that it's relevant on the episode.

No need to go that fast on replying if you can't. We are pretty much served with what we have.


Anon 04/07/2018 (Sat) 23:15:04 [Preview] No.1169 del
well, I have rewatched the Maud Couple and missed the stream of Fake it Until You Make It.

The Maud Couple, while polarizing, some anons have described it pretty well with being like a Big Bang Theory episode without the laughs behind. There were some sick and hidden dirty jokes in that episode. My highlights are the same as the others: Limestone was kino in this episode and the down side....Pinkie at times,not Mud Briar. At times, Pinkie gets to be funny and other moments, she goes into an insane point but not as insane as Party of One, soo instead of bringing laughter, brings some kind of paranoia.

Fake it Until You Make It is definitely better and more in the line of what we have watched. The concept of Flutteshy´s acting feeld weird. I guess this happens when her stereotype is so one dimensional. We all have thought about her becoming assertive again but instead, it´s about roleplaying too much into role. I thought it would go the predictable route, fucking it up because of her shyness but after the 8th minute or so, the standards are overcome.

I can´t certainly say if Season 8 is better than the rest, but damn, they are going really experimental with the established material and shiny and innocent setup.

Also, I blame Sunset for creating this trend


Anon 04/11/2018 (Wed) 21:51:45 [Preview] No.1200 del
(948.46 KB 1024x724 6 species, 6 hopes.png)
I guess, these will define the line of MLP for the future.

My digits are reserved for them with a friendly pic like the mane 6 did 8 years ago.


Anon 04/12/2018 (Thu) 06:08:19 [Preview] No.1206 del
>>1200

Nice digits.

I wonder how there story will go at the Twilight of the Friendship is Magic series? Will certainly be watching to find out!

>1169
Been avoiding this thread until I see them though I am partly spoilered. Haven't had a chance to see either ep do to general life chaos but I will post my thoughts when I do.


Anon 04/13/2018 (Fri) 23:47:22 [Preview] No.1213 del
>>1206
>Been avoiding this thread until I see them though I am partly spoilered. Haven't had a chance to see either ep do to general life chaos but I will post my thoughts when I do.
Oops sorry about the little spoilers but yeah, feel free to watch anytime you want.


Anon 04/14/2018 (Sat) 23:56:18 [Preview] No.1214 del
About Grannies Gone Wild....
I expected to be a shit or filler episode,even more so than the previous two episodes judging by its cover.
However, I just couldn't but laugh and smile throughout the episode. It's like really weird and random,but at the same time, Berrow delivers a lot of comedy.
Nothing too amazing or outstanding but I must say that I have enjoyed this episode waaaay more than expected. It starts slow but then, it's MLP featuring the Golden Girls and referencing a lot of things in the background (I am not going to spoil them,but indifference about them,absolutely not)

I must say that in terms of enjoyment,I have found this one better than the last two because goddamn,those elder ponies sure know how to have fun and make sexual moments for their age.
It's like the writers want to convince us that age is nothing but a number. Elder ponies don't get the cake for porn because of their old skin but oh boy Granny Smith.....oh boy.

7/10. A really fun episode and definitely Berrow shines in this one.


Anon 04/15/2018 (Sun) 03:36:05 [Preview] No.1215 del
>>1214

Sounds fun! Then again, I am someone who unironically could enjoy Golden Girls at times I am hoping to get caught up this week if my life stuff will subside some.

Note: Don't worry about spoilers, I already knew of the basic premises ad all that jazz and some of the reactions.


Anon 04/16/2018 (Mon) 22:00:55 [Preview] No.1230 del
>>1215
>I am someone who unironically could enjoy Golden Girls at times
is there anything wrong with that? I mean, MLP doesn´t fit into the cool things list to be proud of enjoying either for the outsiders.

>I already knew of the basic premises ad all that jazz and some of the reactions.
Well, yeah. You can see perfectly that /mlp/ has gone nuts about Rick and Morty and Chris Chan ponified. What a rollercoaster and tears to enjoy from the reactions.


Anon 04/20/2018 (Fri) 01:54:04 [Preview] No.1242 del
>>1230

To be fair, Chris Chan was on the ride before we were.

https://youtu.be/Iw9IybMbsI8?t=155
>Some best things you should definitely try before despising is some of the hobbies of those of your own opposite gender like for example if you're a young gentleman I recommend buying yourself a My Little Pony figure.
>And also uhhh you can pretend that the pony is that girl you uhhh want to you want to take out too.
Sorry


Anon 04/27/2018 (Fri) 22:09:38 [Preview] No.1257 del
Well. Where were we? Your perspective on the Surf and Turf ep really hit it home for me on the divorce themes and how they could mean to someone. While I guess that is something I perhaps would've honed in more if I had been more awake, I really am more of a lore/background subtexts person over just paying attention to the lessons themselves.

You probably already saw it but I did manage to catch Grannies Gone Wild. Had a similar opinion to yours on it. Liked more then I would expect. Never thought I'd be wanting to see Dash team up with a bunch of old mares. The end I especially found cute.


Anon 04/27/2018 (Fri) 22:15:53 [Preview] No.1259 del
So, what are your thoughts on Horse Play? I honestly am curious as I have heard Twily fans for years saying that Twilight needs to have a disagreement with Celestia for her character development. Though I wonder if this would be considered acceptable by some or not since it is a relatively non serious matter. Though honestly I have no idea how the ep will go. For all we know it may not eve go that direction.

Anycase glad the site is still up today knocks on wood


Anon 04/27/2018 (Fri) 22:44:46 [Preview] No.1260 del
>>1257
> Your perspective on the Surf and Turf ep really hit it home for me on the divorce themes and how they could mean to someone.
Well yeah, while that existed. I can reflect those thoughts again but it´s what makes it a stand out among the rest. The implication of such taboo theme for children while playing with it in a very subtle manner,is a true paradise of thought and a mundane but powerful moral to show within the episode.
The episode while goign in the usual pace, delivers the antithesis of a letter. Every event is important to Terramar´s decision because he tries to solve a personal problem which he is not able to solve. Said problem was created by himself and his parents didn´t put any pressure on him. Their love is there but he psychologically struggled to put his own perspective about his family to not let them down.

>I perhaps would've honed in more if I had been more awake, I really am more of a lore/background subtexts person over just paying attention to the lessons themselves.
Yeah, it´s perfectly understandable, in fact, this episode reintroduced and continued hippogriffs´lore.
I have caught the moral.....because I had watched the leak 4 months ago. I knew it was a good episode and I enjoyed. However, I didn´t think it was truly that deep until I realized how powerful its moral was the last week before its official release.
When the episode was officially approaching, I started to wonder what made the ep so great and I had plans to check it agian. Those previous days made me realize about the situation of my cousin and I found out between some anonymous opinions that this episode deserved a better score than the rest.
It was a 7 or 7.5 episode but whenever it comes to its theme of divorce, my personal rating went up as soon as I reaffirmed my own statement.

I love it both for the superficial reasons (the new species) and its moral (the divorce and a teenager struggling with his own personal issues about his family)

>Had a similar opinion to yours on it. Liked more then I would expect. Never thought I'd be wanting to see Dash team up with a bunch of old mares. The end I especially found cute.
Yeah, I thought Granny Smith would mean a boring/filler episode like some Apple family member...However, judging a book by its cover isn´t always effective. Grannies Gone Wild is like he Flurry of Emotions of season 8. Expected to be shit because of the character (in theory) and then, it becomes much more enjoyable than the premise told us to think.
Such a cool mare like Dash combined with a bunch of grannies wouldn´t work on paper. Until you see her comical faces, worth of a sitcom show, all the misadventures become really funny and there were a couple of sexual innuendo in the episode.
These old ladies really know how to have fun and prove that age is nothing but a number(Granny Smith showing her mane was a really unexpected bit).
And even with all the comedy, the episode showed some background pony fest and deliver some heavy lore. Introducing Trixie´s father and the reappearance of Svengallop during the dancing scene.

The end is cute indeed. It starts as a "ew, it´s one of those episodes right?" to "I want to see more, why are you leaving it here?" vibes


Anon 04/27/2018 (Fri) 22:56:22 [Preview] No.1261 del
>>1259
>what are your thoughts on Horse Play?
for now, nothing. The only leak I have watched is Surf and/or Turf and I prefer avoiding any spoilers/trailers from any future episodes. Sure I had watched something out there in /mlp/ but I honestly don´t care to remember anything from it.
>I have heard Twily fans for years saying that Twilight needs to have a disagreement with Celestia for her character development
Twilight isn´t made of metal. Sometimes you have to disagree or critique with your idolized ones just as a sign of admiration or love. Not because of bad intentions but because both grow mutually.
This is like Dash with the Wonderbolts. At first, you admir ethem blindly. When you join them, you critique them but love them as well. So Twilight would do. The Best Night Ever showed her blind admiration for Celestia and these days, she loves her but she points and discusses with Celestia as any other normal pony. Time changes perspectives and I believe the idea could happen at anytime.

>I wonder if this would be considered acceptable by some or not since it is a relatively non serious matter.
depends on how much it has been repeated and how the discussion about it went for such topic. I think like in real life, ponies get into serious things over time.

>glad the site is still up today knocks on wood
knock it knock it. It´s never enough when the /end/ is coming. Still, I wish the mods could make me more relieved about the board´s state.

Celestia knows what can happen next.


Anon 04/28/2018 (Sat) 23:30:26 [Preview] No.1283 del
So, I have to say something very important. Something really deep, something that requires a lot of thought to say and most importantly, keep my forms while saying it...


WHY IS CELESTIA TROLLING AT US? DID SHE HAVE 1111 YEARS AND SHE ISN´T GOOD AT ACTING?

ONE LITTLE THING AND ONLY ONE JOB AND SHE STILL FAILED AT IT FOR ONE SINGLE LINE FOR THE PLAY?

1 1 1 1

1

1

1

WORST ACTRESS, USELESS AND SERVES ONLY TO RISE THE SUN. GODDAMN , SHE IS A HACK. WORST PRINCESS OF THE ENTIRE MILLENNIA . WHERE IS LUNA WITH HER REPUBLIC?

the episode is top notch, a strong contender along with Surf and or Turf. I like that little detail of calling her Celestia instead of a Princess. I will review it after yours


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 03:27:28 [Preview] No.1284 del
(1.20 MB 1920x1080 1524944580403.png)
Without seeing your thoughts I will post mine on Horse Play as last time.

First off. Wow, there was a whole lot going on this episode. I'm not sure I'll get to cover all the questions I have. Probably will have to give a rewatch.

I honestly enjoyed this quite a bit. I'd probably say my enjoyment was 8.5/10 at least. Not sure if a critical eye will bring that down or up later. (Something that often happens for me in both directions). Celestia was cute. They gave out a fair bit of screen time without feeling too crowed. Pacing didn't feel off. The lesson wasn't quite what I thought it would be. But it still showed development for Twilight as a character. The moment between her and Celestia was wonderful. The only thing I could even half way complain of was that the show doesn't have as much Celestia and Twily as it should have, but that has been partly fixed as of recent seasons. Interactions like this would have been nice to have happened sooner and with a bit more build up though. As opposed to how Celestia faded into the background rather then being a force in the plot. Often reduced to fan service and what-excuse-do-we-have-to-write-her-out-of-this-problem?

When is the last time we've seen this smile?


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 03:48:57 [Preview] No.1285 del
>>1284

Now onto my many questions and other thoughts

Was Celestia trolling? It almost seems like it. Sure it was nice to see her actually save the day for once but she sure seemed to know a lot about threader and getting everypony together compared to her comical level incompetence for most of the ep. Plus it seems rather odd that Celestia wouldn't know how to act some considering all the ponies she has to put up with as Princess for various political reasons. I know putting up a facade wouldn't necessarily translate 100% to theader but man you'd think she'd be better... she is freaking better, we saw it in the ep. She trolled us.

How the heck does this translate to canon. A lot of lines that could be interpreted in various ways. Interesting they brought cannon from the Journal of the Two Sisters. Wasn't a fair bit of that book discredited in the last couple of seasons? Also, there could be a bit of a conflict with hearts warming eve's story on the whole five scourers being in charge of the sun and moon as opposed to all unicorns. Though this could easily be a post discord measure, but the timeline is a bit wonky

Interesting that Luna didn't step in during the tomato throwing and whatnot. Though I completely understand why and it is something that doesn't bug me, I know there are some who will really hate that. Also is she friends with Flur?

Apple Jack sure proving the premise of the Princess Apple Jack threads this episode.

Loved Pinkie's antics this episode. Especially the marshmallow!


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 03:56:55 [Preview] No.1286 del
(1.42 MB 2301x1581 1524930384863.jpg)
>>1283
>WHY IS CELESTIA TROLLING AT US? DID SHE HAVE 1111 YEARS AND SHE ISN´T GOOD AT ACTING?

I KNOW RIGHT? COMPLETELY ARTIFICIAL COMFLICT!

>I like that little detail of calling her Celestia instead of a Princess

Me too. Hope we get to see some causal interaction later this season.

>I will review it after yours

Post away!


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 14:32:34 [Preview] No.1293 del
>>1284
>Wow, there was a whole lot going on this episode. I'm not sure I'll get to cover all the questions I have. Probably will have to give a rewatch.
So I will tonight. There are a lot of things to judge.....after watching Blade Runner 2049 with a friend. Finally I am going to see it.
>They gave out a fair bit of screen time without feeling too crowed. Pacing didn't feel off. The lesson wasn't quite what I thought it would be. But it still showed development for Twilight as a character.
Yep, a random anon of /mlp/ said that this felt like an episode from season 2. And with all the new students and better animation, it felt like that. Cute, simple and spontaneous with the comedy.
>The moment between her and Celestia was wonderful. The only thing I could even half way complain of was that the show doesn't have as much Celestia and Twily as it should have, but that has been partly fixed as of recent seasons.
I will get into it down below....
>When is the last time we've seen this smile?
Twilight has been pretty chill this season. I swear that cuteness is reaching levels that shouldn´t be allowed to question. Surf and or Turf was her vacation and this play was her wet dream becoming a reality.


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 14:45:35 [Preview] No.1294 del
>>1285
>Was Celestia trolling? It almost seems like it.
Kind of. It´s pretty ambiguous.

>it seems rather odd that Celestia wouldn't know how to act some considering all the ponies she has to put up with as Princess for various political reasons. I know putting up a facade wouldn't necessarily translate 100% to theader but man you'd think she'd be better... she is freaking better, we saw it in the ep. She trolled us.
it´s more like she likes to lead the things and prefers for others to act than acting by herself. Does she know how to act? She does. However, she pretended to be bad because while the gesture from Twilight seems to be nice, she didn´t actually wanted to be the protagonist. She prefers staying in the background like she has always done before. She knows how to act, just that her acting is spent on trolling rather than playing a role.
>How the heck does this translate to canon. A lot of lines that could be interpreted in various ways.
Well yeah, eveything that involves Celestia and the timeline before the Mane 6 is kind of confusing basically because writers didn´t know what to do.
Still,it´s nice to see some parts of the Journal placed in the show >>1286.
>Wasn't a fair bit of that book discredited in the last couple of seasons?
I didn´t follow it closely but it seems that some fans discredited it mostly because of random tweets or misconceptions between their interpretations. I honestly don´t know how its position was before this episode.
>the timeline is a bit wonky
because it is unavoidable to create one out of nowhere even if that makes important plotholes.
>Also is she friends with Flur?
We don´t what Luna does in Canterlot in her free time, but yeah, she has a bit of social life out there.

>Apple Jack sure proving the premise of the Princess Apple Jack threads this episode.
Writers confirmed to be lurk and being huge followers of the Princess Applejack. It wouldn´t surprise me if they posted some screencaps from it in their Twitter profiles or mention them in some convention........

it could happen...

>Loved Pinkie's antics this episode. Especially the marshmallow!
Yeah. For me the best moment from her was buying the illegal fireworks from Trixie. Boy that part was a highlight.


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 14:54:40 [Preview] No.1295 del
so now, here it comes my review from the episode.
The episode itself is pretty enjoyable and we have received a good streak of episodes, two of them being really strong contenders for the best of the season.
Comedy was at its pure point, everyone was in character,especially the Mane 6 in general. Pinkie delivered her chaotic ideas, AJ was the reasonable one, Dolores slapped Twilight´s princesshood so hard that it could be heard from the other side of the screen, Fluttershy showed her stage fear (referencing Filli Vanlli) and the students collaborated for the interpretation, Spike sure showed his will and ironic phrases in the stage and Rainbow fucked it up by telling everyone the upcoming play.

With all the secondary characters aside, putting their part on this episode, it´s time to focus about the two stars from here....


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 15:09:59 [Preview] No.1296 del
So, more like an review, these are more my thoughts that the fandom has considered when it comes to these two protagonists.
After watching it, I´ve come to realize that we (both the writers and fandom) have been immature and really dramatic in the canon topics.
This episode made me realize that the Twilicorn shitshow was unnecessary. Mostly because princess hood is viewed as a different line to be a character, so it changes everything and the powerful position implies a different contact, lack of warmth after the celebration and loss of identity because of privileged positions that no one will ever have.
What has happened in this episode is the same as the Netherlands monarchy have celebrated their own birthday, they are people despite their position.
So it means that we all thought that Twilight being relatable and a cute pony would be lost from season 4 onwards. With Cadence that didn´t happen, neither was Luna, nor Twilight has done after MMC......and in the end, it isn´t for the the so claimed deity: Celestia.
Celestia has lived a lot and has been considered immortal and a demiGod.....when she, along with her sister, was a student from Starswirl. Who is the ultimate God here? Starswirl is also revived from its sacrifice and he hasn´t shown any sign of being a God either.
The headcanons about alicorns or deities have not been found, nor they are different from the rest of the ponies. Luna felt closer despite her position because she had an episode like Luna Eclipsed or Magic Sheep where she showed her personal emo but funny side. That leaves Celestia being the one responsible for everything that happened during those 1000 years, to the point we have asked ourselves if she was a good princess to hold everything. Well, she is not the only one nor the founder of everything. The Wonderbolts exist and so the Royal Guard, at least, they were able to protect by themselves by not going to unknown places.

But here is the catch:

Celestia is not the ultimate deity to follow, just because she has a good amount of years from his back, that doesn´t mean she has all the answers nor she is able to wipe out everyone from existence. She is a Royal figure and the peak of self defense.


Anon 04/29/2018 (Sun) 15:32:00 [Preview] No.1297 del
Celestia isn´t the Goddess we all have desired or looked for. The one who makes everything relevant......is Twilight, in front of our faces since the first second.
Both in the show and in the timeline , Twilight and the Mane 6 have developed themselves and have been the focus of this show. Their actions are more relevant than the rest and they by accident or intentionally, serve as a plot device to make everything else important. They are the key for everything. So the CMC came after, the species(griffons, seaponies, changelings,dragons...) came after because of their open mind to travel and have new experiences, Luna redeemed herself because of them, Candy and Shining Armor hone because of being related to Twilight all of a sudden.... basically everything they touch or the screen decides to be touched starts to get relevant.

Celestia however, while seemingly being above Twilight and Equestria.....she is not. In fact, she was not a character from the start, but an ARCHETYPE. Yep, a model for Twilight to follow just like Faust wanted. Celestia was considered as the ultimate position at first because she seemingly gave those vibes in the first seasons. Her character and context was not developed, she has been more incomplete than Luna and maybe Cadence.
That´s why I feel confused about her in trolling completely. She wanted to feel in touch with the mane 6.....and so with the audience because her royalty was really overhyped. She admitted that she has learned a lot of things from Twilight (in Celestial Advice) and in seaosn 7, that´s definitely the twist where Celestia becomes an actual character. Writers didn´t know how to make her down to earth so her trolling abilities would put her as a more relatable character.
This episode has deconstructed that being a leader doesn´t mean you are different form the rest. In fact, I think while trolling the mane 6 at the end, she was partially saying the truth. She enjoys from the inside some usual things that happen in the routine outside her princess role. Probably because of boredom or feeling tired about seeing her image being so praised and elevated into top levels (like Twilight does)
Celestia has always been an incomplete character in the end. The Mane 6 and what followed them do. Celestia was considered as them while she didn´t offer anything interesting in front of us. She does when she gets closer and meets the mane 6 more, now integrated in the cast like she has been fakingly considered one of them.

You cannot say that Celestia has been out of character...because she has not had one despite her apparent deity image. We only knew that she liked to troll and have conflicts with her sister, but that´s it. All of this comes...because of the mane cast. They are the ones who have given Celestia a chance to shine and so, make her complete.

I however, must show my amazement about the huge fan content involving Celly without literally nothing on her. Now,it feels that her material is paying off. Celestia having episodes and an actual character.....is ironically fanservice.


Anon 04/30/2018 (Mon) 04:52:19 [Preview] No.1302 del
>>1296
>This episode made me realize that the Twilicorn shitshow was unnecessary. Mostly because princess hood is viewed as a different line to be a character, so it changes everything and the powerful position implies a different contact, lack of warmth after the celebration and loss of identity because of privileged positions that no one will ever have.

I had thoughts like this when it happened to an extent. More so though I was scared that the writers would do that. Not necessarily that I expected to have ta be that way. Even then though the level of drama was way way over the top. Agreed.

>>1297
>Celestia however, while seemingly being above Twilight and Equestria.....she is not. In fact, she was not a character from the start, but an ARCHETYPE. Yep, a model for Twilight to follow just like Faust wanted.
>You cannot say that Celestia has been out of character...because she has not had one despite her apparent deity image. We only knew that she liked to troll and have conflicts with her sister,

I mostly agree. Though I would like to add something to that. Many of the other characters were build up to around what little there was around their earlier appearances ended up being molded into what they where later. Celestia never was. She was stuck (and still is to an extent ) to her archetype and image in terms of personality. Too be fair I never regarded her as a goddess. But she was intended to be at least somewhat powerful and competent. Compare how Chrissy was suprised at defeating her in season 2 to her being seemly dragged away by changing drones in season 6. Her undoing Twilight's want it need it spell compared to her some of her more recent appearances where it almost seems to have some trouble with more advanced magic. These implications slowly died as the show continued. As Twilight's studies in magic became a fact about her character rather then an active plotline. And having her being implied powerful became more of a plot inconvenience. Basically the way I see it, unlike the most of the other characters, she suffered from nerfing the other princess had but also never had any of what was implied shown or her roles expanded any (Luna with deep dream dives, Cadence as ruler of the crystal empire.) So she just kind of was reduced to prop. She was only there because she had to be there. They didn't make her be much of a force in Twilight's life as an alicorn. They didn't show doing any secondary royal duties. Her regalness became a prision that prevented her from being ever having any small problems and slice of life stuff with her and so she rotted.

I do agree this ep felt very much like a season 2 ep. It was nice to see Celestia in a fun simple situation

Note I may expand/reword some of my stuff later when I'm more awake but I think I managed to convey the gist of my thoughts.


Anon 05/12/2018 (Sat) 21:40:42 [Preview] No.1368 del
so, while we may be open to discussion for all this season. there have been several topics about it. That means the show is good at that point. All the talks we have pointed out about the last 4 episodes and School Daze show that this season is doing alright and sometimes, it goes with implied things to keep things interesting, even with completely new characters they manage to make it really entertaining without any nostalgia in mind.

That´s fine and I can say the show has received a very nice streak from Grannies Gone Wild to The Parent Map. There´s no problem when new writers appear into the staff because these 4 episodes were written by newcomers (except Berrow for GGW) and hey, quality doesn´t necessarily goes downhill with it. I don´t doom say as much as some loud shitposters. I recognize that the show has had up and downs and it´s not perfect nor it shines all the time. We shouldn´t be praising it all the time....

all these explanations, for what exactly?Well....


Anon 05/12/2018 (Sat) 22:12:08 [Preview] No.1369 del
I say some key words like nostalgia or newcomer writers...because that´s what the episode is......for absolute wrong reasons. Turns out that the new writer doesn´t achieve neither the new direction nor the old one.
Non Compete Clause comes as a 2nd part of Fall Weather Friends and personally, that episode felt average to me, season 1 had better episodes than that one. Then, it repeats an overused cliche that not many desire to watch: being competitive against each other by being idiots about it. And not for only just a part of the ep,it´s the entire plot.

I thought AJ and Rainbow left that side from them long ago and many users were citing Buckball Season (from Season 6) as putting their differences apart and letting others in for it. They are friends and while it´s nice to be competitive sometimes, the dynamic just doesn´t work as much as one would expect.What I try to say is that while the writer tries to make callback to that old episode, the new circumstances for it suffer from it.

Basically, the student 6 is great by itself and we saw that in the opener, they could learn and have adventures between each other nicely. However, the potential gets reduced to cute and funny moments in some lines and gets dragged down by Aj and Rainbow and this problem gets carried during all the episode.... for some reason.

Why did we need this plot device? Do something with the students or just put RD and AJ with a different dynamic but not with this one.
Whenever you see the episode, you can draw your own potential plotlines and make on your own which way the episode should have gone. I warned some fags about this one( I watched the leak) and some innocents wasted their illusions and hype about this episode.

Anwyay, if you are going to see it, I would recommend just to point out the good things from it and that´s it.
The Student 6 delivered what they could, Pinkie with one line just stole it and these cutie pies that I am posting.

Have a field with this one, it´s completely understandable to bitch and say shit about it. I rarely encourage that but I think it´s a good moment to post some bitter thoughts. Not even EqD nor Reddit can defend it and the strawpoll in /mlp/ says everything. This rating distribution hasn´t appeared since Carts Before the Ponies or Princess Spike.

Neighsay won this time. He may be the only winner.


Anon 05/12/2018 (Sat) 22:18:30 [Preview] No.1370 del
(93.64 KB 1225x893 1526163324288.jpg)
(177.47 KB 1225x893 1526163361200.jpg)


Anon 05/14/2018 (Mon) 02:39:28 [Preview] No.1371 del
Note: had a busy weekend funeral stuff, you get the picture and I haven't been to /mlp/ nor any of the other places I lurk and seen the reaction, but I take it it was quite negative. I only read your replies partly, because if there is something negative and I'm comming in fully blind I feel like it could be good to have a perspective that was untainted by any collective reactions. Not saying yours was, as I haven't read your post fully nor have a understanding of whats going on. Now with the dark stuff mostly out of the way I'll probably have enough time to catch up with ya. Expect my thoughts on whatever happened soon! Just making this post just in case I don't get to it super soon (as in next 24 hours).


Anon 05/14/2018 (Mon) 04:19:04 [Preview] No.1372 del
>How long has the school been going!?
>Okay so the school has been going on for months and they still haven't had one fieldtrip?
>Everycreature seems so forced at some points. Though this is our first episode outside the season premier really focused on the school so I'll see if I get used to it.
>AJ and RD are acting completely retarded.
>Students seem already good at friendship in all limited instances we've seen so far.

Yeah. I can see the negative reaction. Though the base concept wasn't bad the execution was awful. It shouldn't have been more subtle with a slow build up to a point where they done goofed. Rather then having it blow up in their faces completely three times and it being blatantly in front of the students from the start. Another thing that is of a slight concern is them never having time to flush out the student's much as we are going to have only one third of the season devoted to them as a group. They should have one episode per character at least, so this is one wasted. They only showed them as a group and RD and AJ had the POV for most of the episode. Also it having been going on for several months kind of making them having new experiences and being excited for things seem really weird. It would be kind of strange to have them in future episodes being shown new parts of ponyville and what not. Now I know the show doesn't always have a linear timeline (episodes set in fall then spring then winter then spring again), but with the recent exposition about the movie and them setting up with a theme this season it seemed like this season would be more so with a new transition feeling they'd be going for in the earlier episodes.

3.5/10 for me. Though I can't say it was the worst, I didn't really enjoy it much at all.


Anon 05/14/2018 (Mon) 04:32:02 [Preview] No.1373 del
>>1369
>Basically, the student 6 is great by itself and we saw that in the opener, they could learn and have adventures between each other nicely. However, the potential gets reduced to cute and funny moments in some lines and gets dragged down by Aj and Rainbow and this problem gets carried during all the episode.... for some reason.

That's what I mean. Such a waste considering are limited time with'em.

>Whenever you see the episode, you can draw your own potential plotlines and make on your own which way the episode should have gone. I warned some fags about this one( I watched the leak) and some innocents wasted their illusions and hype about this episode.

Basically this.

>Anwyay, if you are going to see it, I would recommend just to point out the good things from it and that´s it.
The Student 6 delivered what they could, Pinkie with one line just stole it and these cutie pies that I am posting.
Didn't read down this far. That would've been better I suppose because this episode wasn't bad in a fantastic way but a mediocre one.

I guess there is not much else to say on the episode itself. Hopefully it's just a fluke. Welp, I have yet to catch last week episode but probably will do so tomorrow.


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 21:21:22 [Preview] No.1374 del
>>1371
>I haven't been to /mlp/ nor any of the other places I lurk and seen the reaction, but I take it it was quite negative.
Well, it was negative but not too dramatic. The leaks helped to not make it a complete shitshow. Instead, they went for something else to get entertained. I personally was asking for Ocellus art because that´s a better entertainment that this one.
>I feel like it could be good to have a perspective that was untainted by any collective reactions.
It´s completely fine and in fact, it shows a truly personal view. But for this one, it was for the better to know the expectations. For good episodes, I won´t spoil until some reply or something else.
>Just making this post just in case I don't get to it super soon
you posted them later. The thing is me because I have been busy as well during these last 3 days.


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 21:41:38 [Preview] No.1375 del
>>1372
>the school has been going on for months
sooo, the timeline explains that we have been going for several months in less than 8 episodes...weird. Unless the Mount Aris trip was long to take or that background stuff happens to point out a sign for it, then I don´t know how time went so fast over there.
>AJ and RD are acting completely retarded.
after 8 seasons. The gif >>1374 is well deserved
>a slight concern is them never having time to flush out the student's much as we are going to have only one third of the season devoted to them as a group
well, yeah. This was supposed to make them grow a bit and shine because you know they are going to become relevant sooner or later. but nope, conflict and duel to see which pony has the biggest brain for going full retard mode.
>They should have one episode per character at least, so this is one wasted.
There are but this one was the biggest let down of the bunch. They were supportive in the background in Horse Play though.

>it having been going on for several months kind of making them having new experiences and being excited for things seem really weird
it would have made sense to put this episode as the 3rd or 4th one and instead of saying months, say that it´s been weeks. That short period would have helped to fit these interactions.

>It would be kind of strange to have them in future episodes being shown new parts of ponyville and what not
At least, we the audience,know that they are going to be the focus. What you have said, it´s going to happen.

>with the recent exposition about the movie and them setting up with a theme this season it seemed like this season would be more so with a new transition feeling they'd be going for in the earlier episodes.

Party of One with Silver Stream when?
Nah seriously, I certainly agree with your lines. But it gives those vibes because of the retake on simple morals but with a different perspective than the original seasons had. The show is going in a cycle on purpose but the lessons delivered are very different. Your line could justify somehow why we went back to Fall Weather Friends all over again but still doesn´t justify the let down.

>3.5/10 for me. Though I can't say it was the worst, I didn't really enjoy it much at all.
The expected rating. Those who were rating it 8 or higher in the poll must have trolled to us


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 21:52:13 [Preview] No.1376 del
>>1373
>Such a waste considering are limited time with'em.
who knows? Mr. Bones doesn´t tell us where this is going nor where we can stop. Put your seat belt on because we still have season 9.

>this episode wasn't bad in a fantastic way but a mediocre one.
it´s mostly uninteresting....for a slice of life series in which nothing is filler and yet, it´s hardly rewarding. The closest to a reward are Ocellus as a seapony and some funny reactions that could serve for shitposts

>I guess there is not much else to say on the episode itself. Hopefully it's just a fluke. Welp, I have yet to catch last week episode but probably will do so tomorrow.
The Parent Map is a good episode. You are going to like a very specific detail very much. About the next episode, I have heard very good things about it. The best episodes come next to each other in this series for some reason.
Pinkie Apple Pie--> Rainbow Falls and then Three´s a Crowd and Pinkie Pride
Somepony to Watch Over Me-----> Maud Pie
The Saddle Row Review----> AJ´s Day Off
Honest Apple -----> A Royal Problem
Somehow MLP never ceases to amaze me the roller coaster it has been through these years.


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 21:58:37 [Preview] No.1377 del
Wow I loved the parent map. Probably my favorite episode of the season so far. I liked it mainly for the town. It felt like its own little corner of Equestria. This place truly felt isolated to me for some reason, considering how interconnected things have gotten in the later seasons (It took us at least a day and night by train to get ta Appleloosa, but now we can ride on a hot air balloon just standing all the way to Las Pegasus farther down on the map!). There was just this /confy/ vibe from it that I really loved. Also the Dad really works for Dolores' bridge building backstory doesn't it? The fact that Stellar Flare is such a capitalist and that Firelight is such a traditionalist being only a minor deal in the background just cracked me up. It wasn't old vs new or capitalism vs the little guy like so many would have made it. I can't think of much of a complaint other then that the Cutie Map felt just arbitrarily thrown in there to serve the plot again. I feel like this though could be more in service to the cutie map itself, trying to keep it relevant amist all the other things they have to jungle around now. I mean, their trying to keep it around with both all the crap of season 7 final, season 8 premier, the movie, and various other plotlines from over the years. Honestly something is going to have to give or get sidelined at this point.

Also I wonder what happened to Dolores' Mother and Sunburst's father, I doubt will have it answered, but it is something that I will ponder away.

Well, anyway a good episode 8/10 for me.


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 22:12:02 [Preview] No.1378 del
>>1375
>sooo, the timeline explains that we have been going for several months in less than 8 episodes...weird. Unless the Mount Aris trip was long to take or that background stuff happens to point out a sign for it, then I don´t know how time went so fast over there.
>it would have made sense to put this episode as the 3rd or 4th one and instead of saying months, say that it´s been weeks. That short period would have helped to fit these interactions.

Just leads to a lot of questions. Whether or not they acknowledge it or stuff comes up that conflicts later on in the season. Agree, they could've completely avoided it if they had gone with teacher of the week rather then month. I wonder with all the stuff they have to manage now if the timeline and lore are going to go insane.

>The show is going in a cycle on purpose but the lessons delivered are very different. Your line could justify somehow why we went back to Fall Weather Friends all over again but still doesn´t justify the let down.

Exactly, it's not that they retreaded old ground it's how poorly it was done. Because even with all the supposed character development with AJ and RD they could have had them still competing without them being retarded from the get go. Or made it focused on some of the studet6 themselves instead, or a mix. Urg. You get the picture.

>after 8 seasons. The gif >>1374 is well deserved

Oh boy it is.


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 22:24:09 [Preview] No.1379 del
(1.08 MB 1280x720 "_S8E8.png)
>>1376
>You are going to like a very specific detail very much. About the next episode, I have heard very good things about it. The best episodes come next to each other in this series for some reason.

That Dolores has a controlling father in Firelight and that Stellar Flare being such a capitalist means perfectly explains her turn to communism and bridges? Even somewhat in show. Because she'd associate capitalism with what helped sent Sunburst away. or that Dolores was a goth? Indeed I liked many small details from it.

>who knows? Mr. Bones doesn´t tell us where this is going nor where we can stop. Put your seat belt on because we still have season 9.

season 9 could be a complete mess if they try to do all possible fanservice while trying to bring every single plotline to a close. Buckle up indeed

>>1374
>you posted them later. The thing is me because I have been busy as well during these last 3 days.

I know the feeling fam and good luck!


Anon 05/15/2018 (Tue) 22:29:52 [Preview] No.1380 del
>>1377
>I liked it mainly for the town. It felt like its own little corner of Equestria. This place truly felt isolated to me for some reason, considering how interconnected things have gotten in the later seasons
Yeah, it´s ironic. The map and the places get expanded, they feel like closer to home over time yet, the original place where Dolores and Sunburst came from felt slightly off than Dolores´s village after The Cutie Map with less expensive buildings. Modern or good looking places don´t always fill that sense of being at home.
>It took us at least a day and night by train to get ta Appleloosa, but now we can ride on a hot air balloon just standing all the way to Las Pegasus farther down on the map
and to arrive at Mount Aris, the mane 6 had to make it days for Kludgetown and the entire day for getting there. Now, it seems like a couple of hours for the trip since they have founded the new train station as if it was as familiar as the Crystal Empire. Or getting into the Dragonlands would take Spike entire days and in the Guanlet of Fire,he got there without getting tired.

Equestria, where the conquest makes the map closer to your home, because friendship is magic.

>Also the Dad really works for Dolores' bridge building backstory doesn't it
the unexplained backstory for Dolores...after introducing Dolores as a villain and redemption. We received the dessert in season 5 and now, we are getting the main dishes after a couple of seasons. Also, we can guess that Dolores went (ironically for the /end/) full Robert Smith in her teenage years.
>It wasn't old vs new or capitalism vs the little guy like so many would have made it.
Surprisingly they didn´t follow the usual tropes for it. I would get tired of it seeing the same things over and over getting repeated.

>the Cutie Map felt just arbitrarily thrown in there to serve the plot again
especially Sunburst. But oh well, it´s a complaint that will be pointed out as well for other episodes. We have talked about it earlier and we, for sure, complain about that when the map calls....I don´t know, one of the students.

>I feel like this though could be more in service to the cutie map itself, trying to keep it relevant amist all the other things they have to jungle around now. I mean, their trying to keep it around with both all the crap of season 7 final, season 8 premier, the movie, and various other plotlines from over the years. Honestly something is going to have to give or get sidelined at this point.

But then, the map is God. I wonder if the series finale shows that using the map too much becomes in negative energy in pony mode. Full of anti friendship just like happened in Dragon Ball GT with Shenron using the Dragon Balls constantly. If the map is doing that as a living being and not just magic, the possibility of creating its other side could potentially happen.

>what happened to Dolores' Mother and Sunburst's father, I doubt will have it answered, but it is something that I will ponder away.
I hope it´s not death, again.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 03:03:52 [Preview] No.1381 del
>>1380
>Yeah, it´s ironic. The map and the places get expanded, they feel like closer to home over time yet, the original place where Dolores and Sunburst came from felt slightly off than Dolores´s village after The Cutie Map with less expensive buildings. Modern or good looking places don´t always fill that sense of being at home.

I suppose the modernness plays a part. As opposed to a fantasy with some modern tech and analogs thrown in, such an enchanted magic powered engine. As the seasons past they where more willing to thrown in modern stuff without an steampunk or magicpunk theme. Though I don't hold this as a full reason or too much of a complaint as long they don't copy paste earth American culture cut and dry with no horse themed attributes to the motifs and tech they decide to use. As I've pointed out before, we've seen things like modern paper, hoofheald video games, a hydrodams in the first two seasons. Though I do agree that sometimes it has been a bit much in the more recent seasons. I think it is more with the sense of distance, which I would partly attribute to modernness, but also out of a desire to make new and interesting things more accessible for plot's sake. I can understand that they never really established set distances so why could't they do it? Though I remember thinking during season 4 that since the series was starting to really develop a set lore and at the time more fantasy/steampunk stuff as fanservice we'd be going the other way.

>Or getting into the Dragonlands would take Spike entire days and in the Guanlet of Fire,he got there without getting tired.

That's a real good one. Though I don't hold it against the slow too strongly I will say that they have made too many places familiar and uninteresting as a plot convenience. But that's what happened with the Everfree early on. Still it lowers the fun you could have with lower/mid tier hostile forces like they used to have even in some of the slice of life ponyville eps.

>especially Sunburst. But oh well, it´s a complaint that will be pointed out as well for other episodes. We have talked about it earlier and we, for sure, complain about that when the map calls....I don´t know, one of the students.

It probably is a bit early to judge but it seems like the tree is going to become the plot device in charge of secondary characters. Oh well, if we get more episodes like this I can't really complain but it just feels a little forced and unorganic.


>But then, the map is God. I wonder if the series finale shows that using the map too much becomes in negative energy in pony mode. Full of anti friendship just like happened in Dragon Ball GT with Shenron using the Dragon Balls constantly. If the map is doing that as a living being and not just magic, the possibility of creating its other side could potentially happen.

Show has already gone DBZ once, so why not?

>I hope it´s not death, again.
Agreed. Well I hope its not vaguely implied death/there gone now. I guess wouldn't mind it there was some variance to it, one died and one just had a divorce or separated in some way.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 03:09:29 [Preview] No.1382 del
(197.26 KB 900x923 1728850.jpeg)
>>1380
>Also, we can guess that Dolores went (ironically for the /end/) full Robert Smith in her teenage years.

I so want to make some OC because of this. This is awesome on so many levels. I mean, your interest in music and even my exposure to it. Bat ponies and the bat cadence green it just fits the /end/ so well.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 04:54:08 [Preview] No.1386 del
(31.70 KB 640x299 IAmSurprised.JPG)
Surprised that this got turned into a contest between Dolores and Twily. I would've expected Pinkie to have a better showing, along with RD but she isn't as much of a fan fanforite as she was in the early days. Maybe it was a buch of people who didn't want Dolores to win that that tipped it like this.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 22:15:37 [Preview] No.1388 del
>>1379
>or that Dolores was a goth?
mostly I was going for that one. But I like yours better.

>I know the feeling fam and good luck!
same,even we need the lucky bridges every day.

>season 9 could be a complete mess if they try to do all possible fanservice while trying to bring every single plotline to a close.
you know, Slice of Life for 26 episodes in which every crazy headcanon becomes real? That would be crazy and an absolute disaster for everypony...

where do I have to sign? Count me in


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 22:42:59 [Preview] No.1389 del
>>1381
>I don't hold this as a full reason or too much of a complaint as long they don't copy paste earth American culture cut and dry with no horse themed attributes to the motifs and tech they decide to use.
Las Pegasus though. Manehattan though. Appleloosa though, Twilight using a polygraph on Feeling Pinkie Keen though. You know magical places and stuff.

>we've seen things like modern paper, hoofheald video games, a hydrodams in the first two seasons.
I should have read this, yep, you got it.
>I do agree that sometimes it has been a bit much in the more recent seasons. I think it is more with the sense of distance, which I would partly attribute to modernness, but also out of a desire to make new and interesting things more accessible for plot's sake
we are probably seeing that MLP has received so much fantasy and happy rainbows into their world that it´s going in reverse, fantasy is looking for real things and the real world wants fantasy in their lives.

I guess technology makes things easier (the train is still getting overpowered as fuck, you cannot beat that). Though I don´t see that much of modernness in some episodes. It pretty much depends on the episode,the setting and random things in the background. However,save Grannies Gone Wild, I haven´t noticed that much of technology advancements and going further than the standard steampunk era. What makes it feel real,.....are the little details on the morals and ways to tell the story. The diplomatic and dialogue way to solve things in order to expand their places has a pretty close view of actual reality. Instead of feeling magical, the magical/tech things complement for something real, that´s why you feel that way.

>I remember thinking during season 4 that since the series was starting to really develop a set lore and at the time more fantasy/steampunk stuff as fanservice we'd be going the other way.
I said it in my project post. From season 3, nothing is canon because the series could have ended at that point. Princess Twilight Sparkle is the new take of the series that has had its roots on being fanservice. Season 3 was the awkward transition and Season 4 started another direction with the same train.
>I will say that they have made too many places familiar and uninteresting as a plot convenience. But that's what happened with the Everfree early on
Let´s say that ponies frew up. They are not pink innocent creatures. They are used to seeing random and constant menaces coming into their lives. See the parody of the bug bear in Slice of Life, I think Octavia looked down on the mane 6 for repeating these fights over and over.
>it lowers the fun you could have with lower/mid tier hostile forces like they used to have even in some of the slice of life ponyville eps
It isn´t The Mane Thing made fun of it and A Health of Information reminded us what´s so actually horrifying behind it. Nor menacing nor a cheerful place, it has to be dealt with some respect.

>I can't really complain but it just feels a little forced and unorganic.
as long as I enjoy the episodes by themselves I don´t care either. it´s actually 40 seconds for it. They get rid of that plot device pretty quickly. Season 8 has called them two times and they were pretty short with some lore behind it.
>Show has already gone DBZ once
One does not simply repeat DBZ so carelessly and not making it awesome
>one died and one just had a divorce or separated in some way
I guess we have to eat the 2nd dish from the menu to have a chance....someday. Oh well.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 22:50:48 [Preview] No.1390 del
(57.52 KB 410x285 feels good lady.png)
>>1382
>I so want to make some OC because of this.
Don´t hurry up m8. You can do it perfectly...but if you feel like doing it, go without hesitation.

>This is awesome on so many levels. I mean, your interest in music and even my exposure to it. Bat ponies and the bat cadence green it just fits the /end/ so well.
It´s ironic isn´t it. The bridges have covered us in darkness. I mean, she was the mascot for a wordfilter....but making her a full goth in her teenage years goes beyond than anything I could expect. Now, this is canon and oh boy, what a surprise after seeing the conversations taken over here.


Anon 05/16/2018 (Wed) 23:08:53 [Preview] No.1391 del
>>1386
>Surprised that this got turned into a contest between Dolores and Twily.
Mostly because they have something interesting to talk about. Twilight has read a lot of books and sure, her knowledge either bores you or entertains you for a long period. It´really helps when you are meeting with someone who always has something interesting to talk about.
Dolores has a very complex backstory so there could be hard hitting empathy moments when someone is down psychologically. She and Sunset can tell a lot of life advice and introvert thoughts to talk about. They have lived in loneliness and so...does a lot of fans.

>I would've expected Pinkie to have a better showing, along with RD but she isn't as much of a fan favorite as she was in the early days
She is an external ambassador like Spike but while Pinkie is great at establishing relationships or setting a nice party even in the darkest places to chill up, she isn´t certainly the deepest most of the times. However, when she gets into the feelings territory like the last part of Maud Couple, Heartbreakers, Pinkie Pride....oh boy, she really gets into them.

Rainbow has always been a mascot personality than a character and whenever she does something, she always ends up getting the TOP CUNT title.
Is Rainbow actually interesting by herself? Well, the Daring Do books and some episodes like Grannies Gone Wild, Secrets and Pies or Tanks for the Memories make her somewhat less of a cunt and more like that asshole friend that you need to hang out with because of feeling cool and having an adventure with someone who loves that.


>Maybe it was a buch of people who didn't want Dolores to win that that tipped it like this.
Basically what you would expect. There are people who still hate her despite that since the season 5 final, a ton of stories have happened in between.


Anon 05/17/2018 (Thu) 18:22:12 [Preview] No.1395 del
>>1389
>we are probably seeing that MLP has received so much fantasy and happy rainbows into their world that it´s going in reverse, fantasy is looking for real things and the real world wants fantasy in their lives.

I like this thought for some reason.

>However,save Grannies Gone Wild, I haven´t noticed that much of technology advancements and going further than the standard steampunk era.

I think I stated this a long time ago when we were taking about the overhype for season 1: in reality the show has had this mix of tech from the get go, it's only been emphasized to varing degrees. Sometimes I feel like a few things maybe a bit much but I feel like if anything it's more of the interconnectedness over any actual tech shown that does harm to the simple /comfy/ factor that so many blame on tech and meme faces. And you are right, there really hasn't been that much this season.

>I guess technology makes things easier (the train is still getting overpowered as fuck, you cannot beat that).

The train at this point is warping reality if we consider that there is multiple cases of it reaching places that used ta take days.

>Season 3 was the awkward transition and Season 4 started another direction with the same train.

Agreed. Season 3 is when the show shed it's formulaic letters and simpler plot structure, but it was going into uncharted waters. Season 4 is when it was put into pratice.

>It isn´t The Mane Thing made fun of it and A Health of Information reminded us what´s so actually horrifying behind it. Nor menacing nor a cheerful place, it has to be dealt with some respect.

A Health of Information is truly horrifying isn't it? True, and I say this again, for me any criticism of the show is tempered by the fact that we really shouldn't have gotten this at all. As you say, meaning out of nothing. I mean if you went back to the season 2 days and showed them just one of what is now normal faservice they'd be freaked. Even if the show became a dumpster fire it is still our dumpster fire of epicness.


Anon 05/17/2018 (Thu) 18:23:58 [Preview] No.1396 del
>>1390
>Don´t hurry up m8. You can do it perfectly...but if you feel like doing it, go without hesitation.

Don't worry, I'm in no rush. Rushing is what ruins the fun and turns simple things into burdens.


Anon 05/17/2018 (Thu) 18:41:43 [Preview] No.1397 del
(69.38 KB 552x519 958161.png)
>>1391
I agree you 100% on dash. I guess I was just thinking back to the season 2 day height of her fandom. Though honestly I'd thought Twily would be somewhere around 4th or maybe even 5th place if everyone voted truly with their best pony. I mean, I would thought something along the lines of Pinkie getting a combo of her fans and those who would just think of her being the obivious choice because of her being a party pone, then FS or RD, with the Dolores block perhaps holding strong enough to win anyway with the split vote.


Anon 05/21/2018 (Mon) 23:22:31 [Preview] No.1407 del
>>1395
>in reality the show has had this mix of tech from the get go, it's only been emphasized to varing degrees.
Manehaten was introduced in the 1st season...so there you go with the tech department
>Sometimes I feel like a few things maybe a bit much but I feel like if anything it's more of the interconnectedness over any actual tech shown that does harm to the simple /comfy/ factor that so many blame on tech and meme faces. And you are right, there really hasn't been that much this season.
I see where you are going. It´s just that maybe the tech has been more persistent in the episodes as a whole but in the background or too similar to real life. Combine that with the realistic way to deal the morals and stories over the recent seasons....it feels much more advanced than what it is.
>The train at this point is warping reality if we consider that there is multiple cases of it reaching places that used ta take days.
It will be the key for progressing in an open world RPG. Discover a place by hoof and then you gain the instant access. I don´t know if they can access instantly with it to the the hive or the Dragonlands but I bet Dolores or Discord help a bit for that.
>it was going into uncharted waters. Season 4 is when it was put into pratice.
because season 4 had more time to prepare it. S3 felt rushed because they thought they were going to end the series and they changed the scripts in the last hour for continuing. It´s understandable why it´s considered the worst and the most awkward in terms of pacing save for a couple of episodes.
>A Health of Information is truly horrifying isn't it?
For me at least. Becuase it reminds me of those 80s shows in which they leave a little bit of spookiness in the background.

>any criticism of the show is tempered by the fact that we really shouldn't have gotten this at all. As you say, meaning out of nothing
that´s what the fandom did as well,writing fics, making music and art out of nowhere.... for a children show. Much more childish back then than what we have received in the latest seasons. The fandom doesn´t appreciate enough that we are reaching levels that no one expected and with every episode that happens, it reflects the influences from its audience more and more. Out of fucking nothing, literally dust in pinkish rainbows, you create this.
>if you went back to the season 2 days and showed them just one of what is now normal faservice they'd be freaked. Even if the show became a dumpster fire it is still our dumpster fire of epicness.
Well, the perfect example is Derpy talking in the Last Roundup, which made the fandom explode. Now, she is a recurrent character and we take her as a nice pony to watch everytime but not with that excessive hype.
By the way, the dumpster fire still rocks even with its ashes....because the ashes are something compared to nothing,there is something created. Now there is potential for everything and a complete world that while it doesn´t reach WoW levels of big, it´s pretty admirable and worth to exploit for decades.


Anon 05/21/2018 (Mon) 23:24:58 [Preview] No.1408 del
>>1396
>Rushing is what ruins the fun and turns simple things into burdens.
there are some exceptions to that rule but it requires a lot of sacrifice and passion to do that. Basically,time.


Anon 05/21/2018 (Mon) 23:35:20 [Preview] No.1409 del
>>1397
>I guess I was just thinking back to the season 2 day height of her fandom
I wonder how many fans would rate her back then as a character, and not a cool visual mascot for the pony material. 20% cooler because her mane is attractive and she had the swag glasses on back then.

>I'd thought Twily would be somewhere around 4th or maybe even 5th place if everyone voted truly with their best pony.
/mlp/ has constantly circlejerked about her without any lose of rhythm nor autistic love for her. Alicorn or not, she is the protagonist and her nerdy personality leaves a lot of room for suggestive fics with her. Consider that she has certainly shown some questionable signs (like in the Cutie Remark, talking to Rainbow Dash as a filly; moving several times while reading a story to Thorax....). Also she has received the majority of fanart and fictions about her, the 1st character that you are introduced to see and know about in the show. Besides, she has always kept her snarky and cute moments all the time.

>Pinkie getting a combo of her fans and those who would just think of her being the obvious choice
nope, not that obvious
>with the Dolores block perhaps holding strong enough to win anyway with the split vote
only enough to prevent her the victory. I guess that those who voted her was because of her role after To Where and Back Again and getting warmed up with her appearance. Those who had liked Sunset, would probably vote for Dolores as well because of their similar contexts.



Top | Return | Catalog | Post a reply